It’s been de rigeur for the network TV gasbags the past few nights – the question of Mitt Romney’s faith. Would a Mormon president take orders from Mormon leaders? Allow me to submit that to the degree he is “Mormon,” and not merely “a Mormon,” – lives his faith rather than simply claims to be a member of the club – the answer would be, “Yes.”
A few decades ago the question was “is America ready to elect a Catholic?” The stated fear was he would be taking orders from the Pope. A couple years ago it was whether the nation was ready to elect a woman, or a black. Coded questions with the implied answer: No.
Oops. We elected a Catholic and that worked out. History will tell us how electing a black man worked out, and if the black guy hadn’t won in 2008, we’d have answered the woman question.
We Americans generally claim to be a Christian nation. Certainly the majority of us who claim to belong to a church identify ourselves as members of Christian denominations. And though we often cite freedom of religion as a basic American tenet, that mostly applies only as long as the religion being discussed is Christian.
Contrary to common teaching, this national was not founded on freedom of religion. The Pilgrims did not come here to practice freedom of religion. They came to practice their religion, and specifically not the religious of the English monarch they left behind. A fellow named Roger Williams was a fine member of the Massachusetts Christians, until his beliefs didn’t quite match theirs and he was invited to move down the shore a ways, where he founded Rhode Island.
Most of us proclaim a belief in the one-ness of humankind, existence of One God, and we’re off on the other side of the globe killing Muslims for, mostly, being Muslim.
I can think of several reasons not to elect Mitt Romney. His Mormonism isn’t one of them.